Visit the Archive

Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Toledo Legal News - News Bill calling for restrictions on state agency court settlements targets Kasich administration


An Oakwood lawmaker is going after the health care industry and Gov. John Kasich's administration with the bill he's proposed to require the Ohio Legislature sign off on any consent decree or court-approved settlement involving a state agency that would alter or prohibit enforcement of state law.

Republican Rep. Jim Butler has in mind, specifically, the Healthcare Price Transparency Law passed by the 131st General Assembly.

The legislation was meant to require meaningful transparency in the pricing of healthcare, the lawmaker said.

What's resulted, however, is a more-than-yearlong temporary injunction because implementation of the law is enjoined in a case brought by several healthcare industry groups which argued the law is unconstitutionally vague on the basis that the Ohio Department of Medicaid never drafted and adopted rules to govern price transparency.

"Of course, as with many laws we pass, the rulemaking process related to the Healthcare Price Transparency Law was an important part of the law's implementation because technical issues and definitions were supposed to be hammered out there, after input from healthcare stakeholders," Butler said during testimony last week. "For example, rules would have defined 'emergency' which the transparency law naturally exempts from the requirement to provide a good faith estimate."

The lawmaker recounted that counsel for the Medicaid director and the state immediately agreed to the temporary injunction, which was not seen as a surprise in light of the Kasich Administration's refusal to draft rules pursuant to the duly enacted law.

"If there was any doubt the Kasich Administration was working with the healthcare industry plaintiffs to try to judicially repeal the law, the Kasich Administration later jointly proposed extending the injunction for more than six months so (the governor) could repeal the law in the budget, which he duly attempted in his introduced version of the 2017 budget bill," Butler blasted.

House Bill 301 would require a state agency, public official or public employee sued in a civil action, to submit a consent decree or settlement that would alter or prohibit the enforcement of state law to the General Assembly for approval before the agency or official may agree to the consent decree.

Any consent decree or settlement that would alter or prohibit the enforcement of state law in such a way and not approved by the legislature would be deemed void.

The lawmaker noted that while House members seated for Government Accountability and Oversight Committee may not be as interested in the Healthcare Price Transparency Law standoff as he, the circumstances could be applied to any law.

"Imagine such a scenario unfolding in the future when the legislature is controlled by one party and the executive branch is held by the other," Butler said. "Do we really want a governor to be able to unilaterally circumvent the legislative process?

"I believe the peoples' duly elected lawmakers ought to have more say regarding what the law is or is not than a select few, possibly unelected individuals, potentially working together to the benefit of a particular special interest."

Under HB 301, the General Assembly would have 90 days after the state agency or public official applies for approval to enact a bill approving a consent decree.

If the General Assembly passes a bill approving the consent decree within 90 days, the state agency or public official may agree to it.

"The legislature is the peoples' branch of government," the lawmaker concluded. "House Bill 301 will prevent the further erosion of the power and standing of this body, and it will ensure that the General Assembly, as representatives of the people, remains an equal partner in running our government as proclaimed in our constitution."

Eight fellow House members joined Butler to cosponsor the measure, which had not been scheduled a second hearing at the time of publication.

KEITH ARNOLD, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

Inaugural Rockets’ Wine Night set for Wednesday, Feb. 21 vs. EMU

The University of Toledo will host the inaugural Rockets' Wine Night at Savage Arena prior to the women's basketball game vs. Eastern Michigan on Wednesday, Feb. 21. Heidelberg Distributing will feature 12 of their most popular wines in the Fetterman Practice Gym beginning at 5:30 p.m. Tipoff for the basketball game is 7:00 p.m.

Date Published: February 19, 2018

Ohio Wildlife Diversity Conference examines Ohio’s predators

Join us as we welcome experts from here in Ohio and across the country to examine Ohio’s predatory animals at the 34th annual Ohio Wildlife Diversity Conference hosted by the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) on Tuesday, March 6, at the Ohio Union on The Ohio State University’s campus in Columbus.

Date Published: February 19, 2018

Pending home sales tick up 0.5 percent in December

Pending home sales were up slightly in December for the third consecutive month, according to the National Association of Realtors®. In 2018, existing-home sales and price growth are forecast to moderate, primarily because of the new tax law's expected impact in high-cost housing markets.

Date Published: February 19, 2018

5 'healthy' habits worth giving up

(StatePoint) While most weight loss proclamations are well-intentioned, sometimes they look better on paper than in practice, actually doing more harm than good. Here are five so-called “healthy” habits worth giving up on, as well as better solutions.

Date Published: February 16, 2018

5 tips for working adults returning to college

(BPT) Most working professionals want to advance their skills, land that promotion and get a raise. However, some 36 million adults face a significant barrier to achieving their goals and aspirations: They still need to complete a significant amount of coursework in order to earn a college degree.

Date Published: February 16, 2018

Professor Stephen J. Wermiel to receive ABA Robert F. Drinan Award

The American Bar Association Section of Civil Rights and Social Justice honored Washington, D.C., attorney and professor Stephen J. Wermiel with its Robert F. Drinan Award on Feb. 2 during the ABA Midyear Meeting at the Fairmont Waterfront Hotel in Vancouver.

Date Published: February 16, 2018

Proposal designed to stem $4 million soil, water conservation shortfall

Devised initially as a budget amendment, House Bill 463 secured a first hearing before Energy and Natural Resources Committee members in the Ohio House of Representatives recently after the amendment was not included in the budget bill approved earlier this session.

Date Published: February 16, 2018

Toledo to hold 12th-annual ‘Rockets for the Cure’ day on Feb. 17 vs. WMU

Toledo will hold its 12th-annual 'Rockets for the Cure' day on Saturday, Feb. 17, as the Midnight Blue & Gold entertain Western Michigan at 2:00 p.m. in Savage Arena. The MAC West Division showdown will help benefit the Susan G. Komen for the Cure of Northwest Ohio, the Eleanor N. Dana Cancer Center and the University of Toledo Center for Health and Successful Living. The Rockets encourage everyone in attendance to wear pink in support of cancer research.

Date Published: February 16, 2018

BWC awards $377,000 in grants to protect Ohio firefighters

Thirty-nine Ohio fire departments will share $376,517 in grants from the Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation (BWC) under a new program to reduce firefighters' exposure to toxic environmental elements.

Date Published: February 15, 2018

Leader of Las Vegas to Columbus marijuana ring sentenced

Adrian A. Douglas, 48, of Columbus, was sentenced in U.S. District Court to 144 months in prison for conspiracy to distribute more than 1,000 kilograms of marijuana and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Douglas led a Central Ohio marijuana trafficking ring that involved receiving UPS shipments of the drug from Las Vegas and mailing cash back to the supplier. He pleaded guilty to the two charges in June 2017.

Date Published: February 15, 2018

Ohio to share insurance expertise with national insurance organization

Director Jillian Froment announced that the Ohio Department of Insurance is serving on 18 National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) committees and task forces in 2018 to collaborate with other states on critical insurance matters such as innovation and technology, protecting seniors, fighting fraud, appropriate business conduct, and the effective financial condition monitoring of companies. Froment will serve as Vice Chair of the Life Insurance and Annuities Committee.

Date Published: February 15, 2018

UT’s Woodside, Adeniyi chosen to participate in 2018 NFL Combine

Former Toledo football players Logan Woodside and Olasunkanmi Adeniyi have been chosen to participate in the 2018 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis, the NFL recently announced. The combine will take place from Feb. 27-March 5.

Date Published: February 15, 2018