Toledo Legal News - News East Cleveland Court can hear dereliction-of-duty cases against five Cleveland police supervisors


East Cleveland Municipal Court may decide whether it has jurisdiction to try five Cleveland Police Department supervisors charged with dereliction of duty in the aftermath of a 2012 pursuit that left two people dead when police fired 137 bullets at the suspects, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled recently.

The Supreme Court lifted a writ of prohibition granted by the Eighth District Court of Appeals, which prevented East Cleveland Municipal Court Judge William L. Dawson from hearing the misdemeanor charges against the five officers. In a unanimous per curiam opinion, the Supreme Court rejected the officers’ argument that the municipal court “patently and unambiguously lacked jurisdiction” to hear the case under the “jurisdictional-priority rule” because Cuyahoga County prosecutors first filed the same charges in Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court. The officers claimed that even though the prosecutors dismissed the charges in common pleas court, starting the charges in that court meant no other court had jurisdiction to hear the claims.

Pursuit Ended in East Cleveland

On Nov. 29, 2012, police pursued a car through Cleveland into East Cleveland, and 13 Cleveland police officers fired 137 bullets at the car resulting in the deaths of Timothy Russell and Malissa Williams.

In May 2014, a Cuyahoga County grand jury indicted police supervisors Randolph Dailey, Patricia Coleman, Michael Donegan, Jason Edens, and Paul Wilson each on two counts of misdemeanor dereliction of duty under R.C. 2921.44(E). The common pleas court scheduled a July 2015 trial, and at a June 2015 pretrial hearing, the county prosecutor’s office notified the court that East Cleveland intended to file identical charges against the five officers in municipal court. The common pleas court responded that it was retaining jurisdiction and starting the trial in July, regardless of the municipal court filing.

Days later, charges were filed in East Cleveland, and Judge Dawson ordered the officers to appear for an arraignment.

Officers Seeks to Block Municipal Court

Two days before the arraignment, the officers sought the writ of prohibition in the Eighth District Court of Appeals, arguing that the jurisdictional-priority rule prevented Judge Dawson from having authority to hear the case. Citing the Supreme Court’s 1968 State ex rel. Coss v. Hoddinott decision, the Court’s opinion explained the jurisdictional-priority rule provides that if two courts each have jurisdiction over a matter, the court in which jurisdiction was first invoked handles the entire matter.

The Eighth District sided with the officers and found Judge Dawson did not have jurisdiction to hear the case. On the day the East Cleveland arraignment was scheduled, prosecutors asked the common pleas court to dismiss the case, which it did, finding that the filing of duplicate charges in municipal court justified dismissal. The county prosecutor and East Cleveland requested the Eighth District not block Judge Dawson, arguing that even if the priority rule had applied, it no longer applied because the common pleas court charges were dismissed.

The Eighth District granted the writ in April 2016, and the prosecutor and city appealed to the Supreme Court.

Writs Granted in Limited Cases

The Court explained that writs of prohibition are granted in limited circumstances to those who can demonstrate they do not have “an adequate remedy in the ordinary course of law.” The opinion explained that typically when the jurisdiction of a court is challenged, the party challenging it must wait for the court to rule on the matter, then appeal the ruling. There is an exception when a court patently and unambiguously lacks jurisdiction, and a writ of prohibition is granted to prevent a court from proceeding, the opinion noted.

The officers argued allowing both the common pleas court and the municipal court to have jurisdiction means that they could face convictions and punishments in both courts for the identical charges. Because that would violate their rights, only one court can have jurisdiction, and it would be the court that first invoked, which was the common pleas court. They argued the second court, the municipal court, could not have jurisdiction.

The prosecutors and city maintain that the rule falls to the side when action is pending in only one court, and they argue that is what the Supreme Court stated in its Coss decision.

In its opinion, the Court noted, “as in Coss, no second prosecution is threatened here. The original charges have been dismissed, and only the municipal court charges remain.” However, the Court did not expressly decide whether the jurisdictional-priority rule applies in the officers’ case.

Officers Can Appeal Judge’s Decision

The Court declined to prohibit Judge Dawson from exercising jurisdiction over this case, a misdemeanor committed within the boundaries of East Cleveland. The Court concluded that if the officers disagree with his actions, they can move to dismiss the charges brought against them, and if they lose, they can appeal the judge’s decision.

2016-0812. State ex rel. Dailey v. Dawson, Slip Opinion No. 2017-Ohio-1350.

Please note: Opinion summaries are prepared by the Office of Public Information for the general public and news media. Opinion summaries are not prepared for every opinion, but only for noteworthy cases. Opinion summaries are not to be considered as official headnotes or syllabi of court opinions. The full text of this and other court opinions are available online.

Dan Trevas, Supreme Court of Ohio

ODA launches 2017 “Ag is Cool!” creative expression contest

The Ohio Department of Agriculture today announced it will begin accepting entries for the 2017 “Agriculture is Cool!” Creative Expression Contest. Children enrolled in school or home schooled in Ohio during the 2016-2017 academic year have until June 5, 2017 to capture their personal interpretation of why Ohio agriculture is cool for their chance to win prizes, including tickets to the Ohio State Fair.

Date Published: April 25, 2017

Ten UT Rockets named to Academic All-MAC Squad

Toledo swimming and diving had 10 student-athletes earn a spot on the 2017 Academic All-Mid-American Conference squad, the league office recently announced. Jessica Avery, Allie Brinkhoff, Bailey Cahill, Allison Dicke, Emily Frederick, Madeline Grubbe, Gabbi Haaraoja, Maggie Hack, Rachael Hester and Katrin Streicher were selected due to their outstanding efforts in the classroom, as well as the pool, in 2016-17.

Date Published: April 25, 2017

Twenty cases certified to Disciplinary Board

The Ohio Board of Professional Conduct recently announced the certification of 20 cases from February through April for formal disciplinary proceedings.

Date Published: April 25, 2017

Fact: Ohio Tuition Trust Authority administers Ohio’s Direct 529 Plan

CollegeAdvantage. Ohio Tuition Trust Authority. Ohio’s 529 Savings Program. Ohio’s 529 Plan. The myriad of terms may have complicated research being done on 529 college savings plans, especially for Ohio residents. For an explanation on what these names describe, let’s start at the beginning.

Date Published: April 24, 2017

Forensic facial reconstruction created for 1989 John Doe

(Marion) Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine and Marion County Sheriff Tim Bailey recently released the facial reconstruction of a man whose skeletal remains were found more than 27 years ago.

Date Published: April 24, 2017

Ohio Department of Agriculture announces new assistant director

Ohio Department of Agriculture (ODA) Director David T. Daniels has appointed former State Representative Tim Derickson as the department’s assistant director. Derickson most recently served as executive director of the Ohio Board of Embalmers and Funeral Directors. One of his many accomplishments in the legislature was sponsorship of HB 89 in March 2011 that established Ohio Agriculture Week, an annual week of recognition dedicated to the state’s largest industry.

Date Published: April 24, 2017

UT to hold “Rocket Sale” at Savage Arena on April 25-26

The University of Toledo Athletic Department is holding a two-day sale of Rocket gear, uniforms and equipment at Savage Arena on Tuesday and Wednesday, April 25-26. Items will include sale items from Rocky's locker, marketing items, and game uniform and other equipment from UT athletic teams.

Date Published: April 24, 2017

High standards of professional conduct apply to insurance needs of Ohio home buyers

Purchasing a home or business property is a time of joy, excitement and inevitably stress generated by the work and by the unfamiliarity buyers have with the layers of demands from loan calculations to insurance commitments being thrust at them. The Ohio Department of Insurance (ODI) may help by providing information about the various insurance types and also through its rigorous regulation of insurance agents, Jillian Froment, ODI director, said.

Date Published: April 21, 2017