Visit the Archive

Bookmark this page on your mobile

QR Code image

What is this?

Toledo Legal News - 1971 Columbus school incident led to landmark Supreme Court decision


The 1975 U.S. Supreme Court Case, Goss vs. Lopez, provided due process rights for students suspensions and expulsions from school.

The case stemmed from Columbus schools issuing 10-day suspensions to nine students from two high schools and one junior high school for misconduct.

The principals did not conduct hearings for students since Ohio law did not require them, according to Oyez, an online resource of Supreme Court cases.

The misconduct took place in February 1971. Six Marion-Franklin High School students, Rudolph Sutton, Tyrone Washington, Susan Cooper, Deborah Fox, Clarence Byars and Bruce Harris, were suspended for disruptive behavior during a demonstration in the auditorium.

Washington was among the demonstrators in the school auditorium while class was conducted, according to court records. He refused the school principal's request to leave when asked.

Sutton attacked a police officer who was removing Washington while the other four were suspended for similar activities.

Dwight Lopez and Betty Crome were students at the now defunct Central High School and McGuffey Junior High School, respectively, and were suspended for other disturbances.

Lopez was suspended for participating in a lunchroom disturbance where school property was damaged.

He testified that 75 other students were suspended from his school the same day, that he did not do any school damage and he was an innocent bystander.

Crome participated in a demonstration at a high school she was not attending. She was arrested with the others and released without being charged. The school suspended her the next day.

Carl Smith was the ninth plaintiff but court records did not specify the reason for his suspension.

A three-judge district court found that the school had violated students' rights under the 14th amendment to deprive any person of life, liberty and property without due process. The court said schools should provide a hearing within three days of the student's removal.

The appellants argued there is no educational right to an education at the public's expense.

But the Supreme Court found in a 5-4 decision that Ohio had extended education rights to its citizen and were considered property interests protected by the due process clause.

"At the outset, appellants contend that, because there is no constitutional right to an education at public expense, the Due Process Clause does not protect against expulsions from the public school system. This position misconceives the nature of the issue, and is refuted by prior decisions," Justice Byron White said in the majority opinion. "The Fourteenth Amendment forbids the state to deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. Protected interests in property are normally 'not created by the Constitution. Rather, they are created and their dimensions are defined' by an independent source such as state statutes or rules."

BRANDON KLEIN, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

Fewer regulations for small Ohio wineries sought

A plan to free the owners of the state's smaller wineries from overburdensome regulation made its way to a committee in the Ohio House of Representatives recently.

Date Published: May 24, 2019

Legislation would expand August sales tax holiday

Just as the current school year races to completion, lawmakers in the Ohio House of Representatives have taken up a measure intended to leave some money in the pockets of Ohio consumers when outfitting their kids for next school year.

Date Published: May 24, 2019

UT’s Cory Mee steps down as Toledo baseball coach

Cory Mee announced Monday, May 20, that he is stepping down from his position as the head baseball coach at The University of Toledo to pursue other opportunities. Mee had served as the Rockets' head coach since 2004.

Date Published: May 24, 2019

Groundbreaking aviation technology set for testing in Ohio

The Ohio Unmanned Aircraft Systems Center and U.S. Air Force Research Laboratory plans to begin testing groundbreaking aviation technology at the Springfield-Beckley Municipal Airport, according to an announcement by Gov. Mike DeWine.

Date Published: May 23, 2019

ODNR to launch new conservation teen advisory council

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) is seeking high school students to serve as founding members of the Conservation Teen Advisory Council (ConTAC), a new initiative to empower the youth voice. ConTAC is designed to become a statewide network of student-leaders working together to enhance ODNR’s youth outreach and program efforts.

Date Published: May 23, 2019

Rockets downed at Ball State, 11-8

The Toledo baseball team played its final game of the 2019 season on May 18, Saturday afternoon, falling to the Ball State Cardinals by a score of 11-8.

Date Published: May 23, 2019

Search of man walking near where gunshots heard was constitutional

A police search of a man walking and talking on his cell phone in an area where gunshots were fired no more than 60 seconds earlier was lawful, and the handgun obtained during the search can be used as evidence, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled recently.

Date Published: May 23, 2019

ODNR Reminds Ohioans to leave young wildlife in the wild

The spring season has arrived, offering many opportunities for Ohioans to help protect young wildlife. Each year, Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) Division of Wildlife offers this simple advice: enjoy wildlife from a distance and leave young animals alone. Wild animals are born to live their lives in the wild, and sometimes good intentions can hurt their chances of survival.

Date Published: May 22, 2019

Rockets eliminated from NCAA tourney on walk-off homer

The Toledo softball team battled to the very end but saw its dream season come to an end on a two-run walk-off home run in a 2-0 loss to Illinois at the NCAA Lexington Regional on Saturday, May 18.

Date Published: May 22, 2019

DeWine, Husted announce InnovateOhio platform

Ohio Governor Mike DeWine and Lt. Governor Jon Husted today announced the launch of the InnovateOhio Platform, which will coordinate data and resources across state government to improve the way Ohio tackles our most challenging problems. It will also streamline technology service across agencies to give Ohio citizens and businesses a better experience when interacting with state government.

Date Published: May 21, 2019

ODNR provides more than $297,500 to help support Ohio rural fire departments

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) Division of Forestry strives to support Ohio’s rural fire departments and the communities they serve. Through the Volunteer Fire Assistance (VFA) grant program, the Division of Forestry recently approved grant funding for 52 projects totaling $297,520 for fire departments in rural parts of eastern and southern Ohio. The protection of life, property and forest resources provided by cooperating fire departments is important to all Ohioans.

Date Published: May 21, 2019

Refund checks coming to tech support scam victims

A dozen Ohioans who fell victim to a widespread tech support scam will soon receive refunds totaling more than $5,000, Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost and the Federal Trade Commission announced recently.

Date Published: May 21, 2019

Supreme Court of Ohio considers declaring an end to “free bite” rule for dogs

The Ohio Supreme Court on Wednesday, May 8th, heard four oral arguments, including one from the city of Cincinnati disputing an interpretation of state law that contends a dog must be designated “dangerous” through a formal process before a local government can seek restitution from a dog owner whose dog has bitten or injured a person or another animal.