Toledo Legal News - Magistrate's ruling against construction firm rejected by appellate court

 

Magistrate's ruling against construction firm rejected by appellate court

KEITH ARNOLD, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

A Franklin County appellate court earlier this month reversed a magistrate's decision against a Columbus-based construction firm, which was deemed responsible for a safety violation, or VSSR, resulting in a worker's injury.

The 10th District Court of Appeals held that the court's magistrate improperly placed significant emphasis upon the fact that there was no testimony to establish that Ruscilli Construction Co. Inc. worker "yanked" on a board. Additionally the magistrate applied a different standard for guarding a hole at a construction site, determining that the cover could not be "easily displaced," rather than "accidentally displaced."

"For these reasons, we grant a limited writ of mandamus directing the commission to vacate its July 2009 order and remand this matter to the (Industrial Commission of Ohio) to adjudicate the application for VSSR and determine the facts, either based upon the record or, if necessary, by holding a new hearing," 10th District Judge John Connor wrote for the court.

Ruscilli filed the original action requesting that the court issue a writ of mandamus ordering the Industrial Commission of Ohio to vacate its award to injured worker David Barno for the safety violation, case summary provided. The court referred the matter to a magistrate, who concluded the commission did not abuse its discretion in granting Barno an additional award for a VSSR because there was some evidence in the record that the cover over a hole at the construction site was constructed in a fashion that allowed it to be accidentally displaced.

The magistrate also concluded that the case was distinguishable from State ex rel. Sheeley v. Indus. Comm., 10th Dist. No. 07AP-1011, 2008-Ohio-4547, because the cover in this case was "easily displaced," resulting in claimant's injuries and prompting the magistrate to recommend awarding compensation to the worker.

Ruscilli, on appeal of the magistrate's decision, argued the magistrate erred by substituting the phrase "not easily displaced" for the "cannot be accidentally displaced" language used in Ohio Adm.Code 4123:1-3-04(D)(1) and by assuming facts unsupported by the evidence in the record.

Additionally, the company argued the magistrate improperly attempted to distinguish this case from State ex rel. Sheeley by using a "lack of resistance test" to determine that Ruscilli had failed to comply with the applicable code provision.

Citing Barno's testimony, the staff hearing officer determined the hole was covered with only a single piece of plywood, but that Ruscilli's safety representative had testified it was standard practice to place two pieces of plywood over every hole and to boldly write the word "hole" on the top piece of plywood, summary provided.

The staff hearing officer found that if two pieces of plywood had been covering the hole, Barno would not have been injured. Additionally, the officer concluded the practice of using two-inch nails to hold two pieces of plywood in place over a hole was not an effective way to guard the hole, given the depth of the boards and the limited amount of the nail that would remain available to secure the boards to the compacted dirt, which could shift.

The staff hearing officer's opinion was based upon Ohio Adm.Code 4123:1-3-04(D)(1), which applies to temporary conditions where there exists the danger of employees or materials falling through the floor, roof, wall opening or stairway at a construction site.

The rule's provision requires that any such opening be guarded. Specifically, subsection (D)(1) provides that "floor openings shall be guarded by a standard guard railing and toeboard or a cover with a safety factor of no less than two and so constructed that the cover cannot be accidentally displaced. ..."

"Our review of the record of proceedings reveals relator's safety officer actually testified that it was standard practice to use just one layer of plywood," Connor continued for the court.

"As a result, the nails only had to penetrate one layer of plywood and more of the nail could be inserted into the ground. Furthermore, the witness testimony appears to establish that the plywood was secured into the concrete floor, rather than into compacted dirt.

"The (staff hearing officer) appears to have incorrectly recalled this relevant and significant testimony of the witnesses and thus relied upon that incorrect testimony in reaching her conclusion that relator failed to use an effective method of guarding the hole. In turn, the magistrate appears to have relied upon much of the same inaccurate testimony."

Ruscilli's counsel, Samuel Pipino, partner in the Columbus firm Wiles Boyle Burkholder & Bringardner Co. LPA, was satisfied with the appellate court's outcome.

"Our client places great value and emphasis on safety in the workplace, and we are pleased this was recognized by the court," he said.

Barno's attorney, Mark Heinzerling of the firm Heinzerling, Goodman & Reinhard LLC, was not immediately available for comment late last week.

Presiding Judge Gary Tyack and fellow 10th District Judge Judith French joined Connor to form the majority.

The case is cited as State ex rel. Ruscilli v. Indus. Comm., 2010-Ohio-4126.

Date Published: September 13, 2010

 

Copyright 2010, The Daily Reporter, 580 S. High St., Columbus, OH.

Magistrate's ruling against construction firm rejected by appellate court

A Franklin County appellate court earlier this month reversed a magistrate's decision against a Columbus-based construction firm, which was deemed responsible for a safety violation, or VSSR, resulting in a worker's injury.

Proposed bill tweaks annexation guidelines

A new bill that includes several of the legislative goals from a state association has been introduced into the Ohio General Assembly.

Taylor Releases Ohio Lottery Commission Performance Audit

Cuyahoga County - Auditor of State Mary Taylor has released the performance audit of the Ohio Lottery Commission. The audit identifies potential savings of more than $2 million annually, and includes several recommendations that could help increase the profitability of the Ohio Lottery.

Court OKs ruling allowing water hook-up at school site

A 5th District Court of Appeals panel has upheld a trial court's ruling in favor of Reynoldsburg City School Board to connect its new schools in Etna Township to city water - instead of Southwest Licking Community Water and Sewer District.

Four cases on schedule for Supreme Court Session at Ohio Northern

The Supreme Court of Ohio confirmed the four cases it will hear at Ohio Northern University on Wednesday, Sept. 29, as part of its semiannual Off-Site Court program.

More than 50 Ohio lawmakers are backing adult guardianship legislation

A new bill proposing state adoption of the Transfer of Adult Guardianship and Protective Proceedings Jurisdiction Act was introduced into the Ohio General Assembly last week.

Court determines fired employee failed to prove discrimination

A federal appeals court in Cincinnati affirmed a U.S. District Court's decision in favor of an Urbana business, despite an appellant's appeal seeking further discovery in an employment-related racial discrimination suit.

Appeal of tax-exempt status scheme examined only for plain error

A 10th District Court of Appeals panel determined a trial court magistrate did not commit plain error by allowing a tax dependency exemption in alternating years for the parents of a minor child.

BGSU named ‘veteran-friendly campus’

(Bowling Green) Transitioning from life on a military base to life on a college campus can be a mission in itself.

Enjoying life after the kids leave the nest

(ARA) A ennui tends to settle upon the houses of parents whose children have all moved away. "Empty Nest Syndrome is a colloquial way of identifying that sense of loss, sadness or emptiness in parents," says Dr. Jim Wasner, chair of Clinical Psychology programs at Argosy University, Schaumburg. "It's that period of transition when a child no longer depends on their parents for a high level of support and care."

Bill would form Opportunity Zones to promote business development throughout Ohio

Rep. Seth Morgan has created a new piece of legislation aimed at stimulating economic growth by tearing through bureaucratic hurdles.  House Bill 576 would authorize the state and local governments to jointly offer a single, lower tax rate and other incentives to businesses that establish operations within designated areas.

Legislation designed to encourage people to seek medical assistance


Inspired by the passing of 21-year-old Sara Lewandoski in 2007, an Ohio lawmaker has introduced a bill designed to prevent a similar loss of life.  House Bill 575, sponsored by Rep. Timothy DeGeeter, would modify current Ohio Revised Code to specify that when a court is sentencing a person for certain drug offenses, it should take into consideration situations in which medical assistance had been sought due to a drug overdose.

Debate between engineer, commissioners of Knox County remains unresolved

According to a 5th District Court of Appeals ruling this week, a Knox County trial court more than likely will revisit a dispute between the local county board of commissioners and the county's engineer.

6th Circuit: Defendant not entitled to relief

A defendant, who pleaded guilty to federal charges without a written plea agreement, was unable to persuade a three_judge panel of the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals that his sentence was substantively unreasonable and the district court erred in formulating his base offense level.

New Edition of Women Rainmakers' Best Marketing Tips Marks 20th Anniversary of ABA Women’s Group

Marketing is crucial to a lawyer’s success, but brainstorming for new ideas takes valuable time. In one quick read, Women Rainmakers’ Best Marketing Tips, Third Edition provides ideas that work for busy lawyers – both women and men.  Recently updated, this practical guide is a collection of easy-to-read helpful hints and strategies collected by Theda Snyder, one of the recognized leaders of women rainmakers nationwide.

Resentencing is a must, 5th District rules on petition

A London Correctional Institution inmate was unable to convince a 5th District Court of Appeals panel that the appellate court should stop the trial court's plan to resentence him as a result of post-release control having been omitted from his initial sentence.

Bill focuses on dyslexia screening, assistance

A bill that would specify dyslexia as a specific learning disability and require a 3-year pilot project to provide early screening and intervention has been introduced into the Ohio General Assembly.

Expert's past conviction not fodder for testimony in workers' comp case

A Franklin County appellate panel accepted the argument of a Washington Courthouse man who alleged a trial court abused its discretion when it allowed cross examination testimony centering on a prior criminal conviction of his expert medical witness.

Capital law professor to present results of online privacy research conducted in the Netherlands

Just weeks removed from a research project in the Netherlands, Dennis D. Hirsch is preparing to offer his preliminary findings to students, alumni and colleagues.

State recovers Medicaid costs from estates

Q: My mother recently died in a nursing home where she was getting Medicaid benefits. I am the executor of her estate, and my lawyer says I have to notify the Ohio Attorney General so the state can recover assets to pay for the Medicaid benefits she received. Why must I do that?