Toledo Legal News - Court of Claims must weigh in on timeliness of rejected bidder claim, justices rule

 

Court of Claims must weigh in on timeliness of rejected bidder claim, justices rule

KEITH ARNOLD, Daily Reporter Staff Writer

The state's high court has determined the preparation costs incurred by a bidder vying for the public contract tied to construction of University of Akron's new football stadium in 2008 may be recovered as long as the rejected bidder sought - but was denied - timely injunctive relief.

The Supreme Court late last month affirmed the 10th District Court of Appeals ruling, which found that the high court's holding in Cementech Inc. v. Fairlawn, 109 Ohio St.3d 475, 2006-Ohio-2991, 849 N.E.2d 24, did not specifically address other types of money damages, such as bid-preparation costs, a plaintiff might assert.

"Upon consideration of the arguments in this case on the availability of reasonable bid-preparation costs as damages, we decline to extend the holding in Cementech to this circumstance," Justice Robert Cupp wrote for the 6-0 court.

"We reach this conclusion because the reasons articulated in Cementech for denying recovery of lost profits as damages do not carry over to the circumstances in which bid-preparation costs are sought after denial of a timely application for injunctive relief. A significant distinguishing factor in those circumstances is the lack of any other remedy for a public authority's wrongful conduct.

"If, for instance, a rejected bidder alleges that a public authority failed to comply with competitive bidding laws and promptly seeks injunctive relief to delay the public-improvement project pending resolution of the dispute, denial of the requested injunctive relief means that determination of the allegation of wrongful conduct by the public authority will not take place until much later in the litigation.

"Under our precedent, once the public-improvement work commences or is completed, the rejected bidder will not be able to perform the public contract even if the bidder demonstrates that its bid was wrongfully rejected.

"In such circumstances, the wrongfully rejected bidder is left with no remedy for the public authority's unlawful conduct, and injunctive relief will no longer serve to deter the public authority's unlawful conduct. Thus, we hold that when a rejected bidder establishes that a public authority violated state competitive-bidding laws in awarding a public-improvement contract, that bidder may recover reasonable bid-preparation costs as damages if that bidder promptly sought, but was denied, injunctive relief and it is later determined that the bidder was wrongfully rejected and injunctive relief is no longer available."

In April 2008, the University of Akron invited bids for various phases of construction work on InfoCision Stadium, court summary detailed. Meccon Inc. submitted its bid. However, in June 2008 the university awarded the HVAC and fire protection contracts on the project to a lower bidder, S.A. Communale.

Meccon subsequently filed suit in the Ohio Court of Claims, alleging the university had violated provisions of the state's competitive bidding law and the terms of the project bid proposal in making its contract awards to S.A., summary continued. Meccon sought a temporary restraining order and temporary and permanent injunctions preventing work on the project from going forward, and also asserted claims for money damages to compensate Meccon for the costs of preparing its bid and additional costs and damages.

Before the Court of Claims could hold an evidentiary hearing on the company's motion for a temporary restraining order, the university moved to dismiss the entire action on the basis that the Court of Claims did not have jurisdiction to hear the case, summary provided.

The Court of Claims granted the motion to dismiss, ruling that under the 2006 Cementech finding, a disappointed bidder on a public contract may obtain only injunctive relief - not money damages - and the Court of Claims' has jurisdiction to hear only cases in which a plaintiff asserts a justiciable claim for money damages against the state.

Meccon appealed the order dismissing its complaint and the 10th District Court of Appeals reversed and remanded the case to the Court of Claims for further proceedings, summary continued. The 10th District found that Cementech only barred disappointed bidders from suing the state to recover money damages for lost profits resulting from alleged bidding irregularities, but did not specifically address other types of money damages a plaintiff might assert, such as the bid preparation costs sought by Meccon in this case.

The university sought and was granted Supreme Court review of the 10th District's ruling.

"When Meccon filed its action for money damages and injunctive relief against the university, it filed it in the Court of Claims. The Court of Claims has exclusive, original jurisdiction over civil suits that request money damages against the state even when ancillary relief, such as an injunction or declaratory judgment, is also sought," Cupp continued, citing R.C. 2743.03(A)(1) and 2743.03(A)(2) and State ex rel. Blackwell v. Crawford, 106 Ohio St.3d 447, 2005-Ohio-5124, 835 N.E.2d 1232. "Therefore, the Court of Claims had jurisdiction to hear Meccon's claim for bid-preparation costs.

"Injunctive relief must be promptly sought as a precondition to those damages, however. ..."

Because the Court of Claims had not settled the question of whether Meccon's request for injunctive relief was timely enough, the Supreme Court determined the lower court must resolve the question.

Cupp's opinion was joined by his fellow justices, while Chief Justice Eric Brown did not participate in the decision.

The case is cited as Meccon, Inc. v. Univ. of Akron, Slip Opinion No. 2010-Ohio-3297.

Date Published: August 3, 2010

 

Copyright 2010, The Daily Reporter, 580 S. High St., Columbus, OH.

Court of Claims must weigh in on timeliness of rejected bidder claim, justices rule

The state's high court has determined the preparation costs incurred by a bidder vying for the public contract tied to construction of University of Akron's new football stadium in 2008 may be recovered as long as the rejected bidder sought - but was denied - timely injunctive relief.

6th Circuit vacates sentence of scam investment broker

A Cincinnati federal appeals court vacated the sentence of an investment broker who pleaded guilty to a charge of mail fraud on the basis it was made in error.

Ex-bank CEO takes over as Ohio's top banking regulator

Carolyn Bradford can't seem to stay retired. She's tried it twice, but now she's unretired again, this time to lead the agency that regulates the state's banks, credit unions, mortgage brokers and even pawnbrokers.

Rockets to host 2011 NCAA Regional Cross Country Championships

The University of Toledo has been selected to host the 2011 NCAA Great Lakes Regional Cross Country Championships at Ottawa Park Golf Course in Toledo.

State fair filled with numerous green features, initiatives

(Columbus) The always popular butter cow at the Ohio State Fair may look good enough to eat, but once the fair ends the butter does not end up spread across toast or mixed in a muffin batter.

Cordray: Federal grant scams targeting Ohioans

(Columbus) Federal grant scams are sweeping through Ohio, Attorney General Richard Cordray has warned.

Court upholds sentence enhancement on drug distribution conviction

A Cincinnati federal appellate court rejected the claims of a defendant who appealed the U.S. District Court's sentence enhancement to his conviction for conspiracy to distribute drugs.

6th Circuit reverses ruling on retaliation claim

A federal appellate court in Cincinnati believes there exists enough facts in the action brought by a Warren County resident that the U.S. District Court should not have dismissed the woman's retaliation claim against a local economic development director and several county institutions.

10th District reverses ruling on substitute teacher's 'resignation'

A Franklin County appellate panel accepted the State Teachers Retirement Board of Ohio's argument that centered on the manner in which a then-substitute teacher employed by Toledo City Schools left her position in 1977 in anticipation of her daughter's birth.

Noted novelist shares lifetime of revelations

The University extended sanctuary to some shady characters — Jazz Age bootleggers, sexual obsessives and high-rolling grifters among them — when acclaimed writer Craig Holden donated his personal papers to the Ward M. Canaday Center for Special Collections in Carlson Library.

Ohio Judicial Center Foundation elects at-large members

A non-profit foundation through which charitable donations can be made to the Supreme Court of Ohio elected two at-large members to its board of directors on Tuesday, July 27th.

Supreme Court rules statute of limitations not applicable in child sex abuse case

A spokesman for the Cuyahoga County prosecutor commended the decision by the Supreme Court of Ohio earlier last week for precluding any notion that at-large offenders may shield themselves from the law through statutory time limits.

6th Circuit says drug sentence not unreasonable

A Cincinnati federal appellate court upheld a decision by the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Columbus sentencing an individual who had been working with federal drug agents to more than 11 years in prison based upon a drug-related conviction.

6th Circuit affirms holding in favor of correctional staff

A federal appellate panel in Cincinnati found that the U.S. District Court for the Southern District Court of Ohio in Columbus correctly dismissed the civil rights action brought by an inmate against Madison Correctional Institution employees in a decision this week.

Old friends start new cafe

Hungry Toledo lawyers have a new, convenient lunch option. Located on the first floor of the Lucas County Common Pleas Courthouse, TJ's Courthouse Café, which opened on Wednesday, is full of both good food and familiar faces.

Sponsor says bill eliminating judgeship would save Belmont County more than $200,000 yearly

House Bill 558, introduced this month in the Ohio General Assembly, would eliminate a Belmont County Court judgeship by combining Northern and Eastern Division Courts in Belmont County and consolidating three divisional courts into two, all in a move to decrease the county's expenses.

Filing of certificates of service at heart of 10th District ruling

A three-judge appellate panel late last month reversed a Franklin County Common Pleas Court decision dismissing a restaurant owner's appeal of an earlier ruling by the village of Obetz which ordered the restaurant's signs be removed as a result of the business apparently ceasing operations.

OSU Moritz gears up for On-Campus Interviewing Program

The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law is gearing up for its On-Campus Interviewing Program, which will bring law firms to campus to interview first-, second- and third-year law students for 2011 summer and permanent positions. Early interviews for the program will take place Aug. 9 through Aug. 18.

Except for subprimes, access to auto loans seems to have improved

According to national reports, at least one segment of the U.S. credit sector may be easing - auto loans.

Rockets to play Miami Hurricanes in 2015, 2016


The University of Toledo will play the University of Miami in a home-and-home football series beginning in 2015, UT Vice President and Athletic Director Mike O’Brien announced yesterday.